Semiotics of Peirce and its Mediating Role Between the Cognitive Sciences and the Comparative Studies of Literature and Music
PDF (Español (España))

Keywords

comparative literature
music
semiotics
Peirce
cognitive sciences. literatura comparada
música
semiótica
Peirce
ciencias cognitivas.

Abstract

Peirce’s is a theory about human knowledge and as such is deeply linked to modern cognitive sciences. The following article pursues a twofold objective. Firstly, it seeks to analyze that intimate link. Its analysis takes into account Peirce’s belief that human beings themselves are signs as well as his notion that the mind is an external phenomenon, the vital role that the ground and interpretant concepts introduced by him have played in the generation and reception of ideas, and finally, his view that human creativity represents a quest for a new intelligibility. The article’s second objective is to assess how well Peirce’s theory of signs is suited to a comparative approach to literature and music. Several key aspects are evaluated, including the tangible process by which signs (qualisigns) come to be defined, Peirce’s notion that meaning dependents on interpretative recreation carried out by other signs, his interest in interpreters and interpretants types and consequently in possible response types specific to every communicative phenomenon, and finally, the various models of referentiality that stem from the relation between the sign and the object.
https://doi.org/10.17811/arc.70.1.2020.269-281
PDF (Español (España))

References

ALEXANDER, THOMAS, M. (1990) «Pragmatic Imagination», Transactions of C. S. Peirce Society, 26, pp. 325-348.

BAJO, TERESA, FERNÁNDEZ, ÁNGEL, RUIZ, MARCOS & GÓMEZ-ARIZA, CARLOS (2016) «Memoria: estructura y funciones», en Bajo Molina, T. et al., coords., Mente y cerebro: De la psicología experimental a la neurociencia cognitiva, Madrid, Alianza Editorial, pp. 205-236.

BARRENA, SARA (2003) La creatividad en Charles S. Peirce: Abducción y razonabilidad, Tesis doctoral, Universidad de Navarra, http://www.unav.es/gep/TesisDoctorales/TesisBarrena.pdf.

BARRENA, SARA (2012) «La traducción como actividad creativa: El caso de Charles S. Peirce». Congreso «Pensar la traducción: La filosofía de camino entre las lenguas», Universidad Carlos III, Madrid, pp. 1-8, http://www.unav.es/gep /TraduccionActividadCreativa.pdf.

BARRENA, SARA & NUBIOLA, JAIME (2007) «Antropología pragmática: El ser humano como signo en crecimiento», en Sellés, J. F., ed., Propuestas antropológicas del siglo XX, Pamplona, Eunsa, pp. 39-58, http://www.unav.es /gep/AntropogiaBarrenaNubiola.html.

BIGAND, EMMANUEL & MCADAMS, STEPHEN, eds. (1994) Penser les sons: Psychologie cognitive de l’audition, Paris, Presses Universitaires de France.

DEBROCK, GUY (1998) «El ingenioso enigma de la abducción», Analogía filosófica, XII, pp. 21-41.

DUBUISSON, DANIEL (1996) Anthropologie poétique: Esquisses pour une anthropologie du texte, Louvain, Peeters.

ECO, UMBERTO (1972) La estructura ausente: Introducción a la semiótica, Barcelona, Lumen.

ECO, UMBERTO (1988) Signo, Barcelona, Labor.

ECO, UMBERTO (2008) Decir casi lo mismo, Barcelona, DeBolsillo.

GARDNER, HOWARD (2001) Estructuras de la mente. Bogotá, FCE.

GONZÁLEZ MARTÍNEZ, MIGUEL ÁNGEL (2015) «Fundamentos de la Semiótica de la Música», en Pozuelo Yvancos, J. M et al., coords., De Re Poetica: Homenaje al profesor D. Manuel Martínez Arnaldos, Murcia, Universidad de Murcia, pp. 383-401.

JABŁONSKI, MACIEJ. (1996) «Values and their Cognition in the Semiotic Theory of Charles S. Peirce», en Tarasti, E., ed., Musical Semiotics in Growth, Bloomington, Indiana University Press, pp. 83-97.

MARTINEZ, JOSÉ LUIZ (2001) Semiosis in Hindustani Music, Delhi, Motilal Banarsidass Publishers.

PEIRCE, CHARLES S. (1992-1998) Collected Papers, vols. 1-8, ed. Hartshorne, Charles et al., Cambridge (MA), Harvard University Press.

PERETZ, ISABELLE & COLTHEART, MAX (2003) «Modularity of Music Processing». Nature Neuroscience, 6, pp. 688-691.

POLICASTRO, EMMA & GARDNER, HOWARD (1999) «From Case Studies to Robust Generalizations: An Approach to the Study of Creativity», en Sternberg, R. J., Handbook of Creativity, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, pp. 213-224.

RODRÍGUEZ, FERNANDO GABRIEL (2016) «Música y significado: Acerca del continuum comunicativo de Ian Cross y de la semioticidad de la experiencia musical», Signa, 25, pp. 903-924.

SPAGNUOLO NANNI, ALEJANDRA (2018) La relación entre literatura y música –a la luz de la semiótica de Peirce– en Trois Chansons de Bilitis (textos poéticos de Pierre Louÿs, música de Claude Debussy), Tesis doctoral, Universidad Complutense de Madrid.

TÖTÖSY DE ZEPETNEK, STEVEN (1998) Comparative Literature: Theory, Method, Application, Amsterdam, Rodopi.